REQUEST A QUOTE

Electrical protection FAQ

Is Selective Coordination Required for Every Electrical System?

Selective coordination requirements depend on the system, its function and the codes adopted for the project. The responsible engineer must identify applicable rules and verify device coordination for the actual design.

POWER DISTRIBUTIONBUILT WITH PURPOSE
Electrical switchgear cabinets in an industrial equipment room
Equipment photograph supplied for illustration.
THE DETAILS MATTERMade for the
work ahead.
MADE IN USAAmerican manufacturing
UL 891Switchboard standard reference

UL 891 is a switchboard standard, not a claim of certification. Confirm applicability and listing for each assembly.

01 / PROJECT INPUTS

The right details make the difference.

Start with the requirements that shape your equipment. Share what you know, and identify what needs discussion.

Discuss your project
PROJECT SPECIFICATIONSREFERENCE / 01
Information to share about your switchgear project
DetailWhat to share
EquipmentType of switchgear or distribution equipment needed
ElectricalRequired voltage, current, and fault-duty criteria
ConfigurationInstallation environment, space, and access requirements
DocumentationDrawings, schedules, applicable standards, and desired listings

Requirements and applicable listings depend on the specific project and equipment.

The short answer: it depends on the system

No. Selective coordination is not automatically required for every electrical system. Whether it applies depends on the system’s use, the applicable code provisions, the edition adopted by the authority having jurisdiction, and project-specific requirements. A statement that it is always required—or never required—can therefore lead to an incorrect design.

Selective coordination means arranging overcurrent protective devices so that, for a specified range of overcurrents, the device closest to a fault opens before upstream devices. The goal is to limit unnecessary loss of power to unaffected portions of a system. The required extent and method of coordination must be determined for the actual installation, not inferred from a general description of the equipment.

Start with the adopted requirements

The project’s electrical engineer should identify the governing codes and standards, their adopted editions, applicable amendments and any requirements imposed by the authority having jurisdiction. Requirements may differ according to the system’s purpose and the circuits involved. Contract documents, owner criteria and design specifications can also impose coordination expectations beyond a minimum code provision.

It is useful to ask which specific circuits, protective devices and operating modes are subject to coordination requirements. Do not assume that one rule applies identically to every feeder, branch circuit, emergency system or source arrangement. The answer should be documented in the project design, with interpretations confirmed by the responsible engineer and, where needed, the authority having jurisdiction.

Why system function matters

Systems serving functions where continuity is especially important may have explicit coordination requirements under applicable rules. Hospitals and other healthcare facilities are a common context for careful review, but the facility name alone does not establish the requirement for every circuit. The engineer must determine which parts of the electrical system are covered and how the adopted rules apply to the particular use and design.

Other projects may have owner-defined continuity goals even when a particular code provision does not require selective coordination across the whole system. For example, an owner may want a fault on one distribution branch to have as little effect as practical on unrelated loads. That goal needs to be translated into a defined coordination scope and evaluated against protection, equipment and operating constraints.

Coordination is an engineering tradeoff

Protective devices cannot be selected by comparing labels alone. Coordination analysis may require device time-current characteristics, available fault-current information, conductor and equipment limits, and the system configuration. The engineer evaluates whether devices coordinate over the required range and whether the proposed settings remain consistent with equipment protection and other project criteria.

In an illustrative system with a main device feeding several branch circuits, a fault on one branch might be cleared by its branch device while the main remains closed. Whether that result is achieved depends on the devices, settings, fault conditions and required coordination range. It should not be promised from a one-line diagram or assumed simply because devices come from the same manufacturer.

There can also be tradeoffs. Adjusting a protective device to improve coordination may affect clearing time or equipment protection. A design may need to balance continuity objectives with the limits of the equipment and the project’s safety and performance requirements. The qualified engineer must evaluate those effects; a supplier should not substitute a general recommendation for a project-specific protection study.

Common misunderstandings to avoid

Selective coordination is not the same as having a backup source, redundant equipment or an arc-resistant enclosure. Those features address different design questions. Nor does a statement that equipment is “coordinated” establish the scope, fault-current range or conditions under which coordination was evaluated. Request the study basis and its assumptions rather than relying on an unqualified label.

Coordination also should not be confused with an enclosure rating or a general claim of code compliance. The responsible project team must verify applicable standards and the specific equipment configuration. Ratings, listing applicability, protective-device combinations and performance depend on the supplied design and must be confirmed against the project specification.

What to confirm before specifying equipment

Before requesting a switchgear or switchboard configuration, provide the project one-line diagram, system voltages, sources, transformer and feeder information, available fault-current data, load and continuity objectives, and any required protective-device models or settings. Identify the applicable code editions, the coordination scope, operating modes such as alternate sources, and the party responsible for the coordination study. The engineer should confirm what information is still preliminary.

Ask whether the design must coordinate for all operating configurations or only defined modes, what device data is needed, and how changes to settings or equipment will be reviewed. For a new equipment order, South Carolina Switchgear Builders can use the project specification to discuss a custom-to-specification design. Availability and lead times depend on the order and require confirmation; final equipment details must be checked against the approved design.

The practical next step is to have the electrical engineer state which requirements apply, define the coordination boundaries and document the verification method. That gives the equipment manufacturer a clear basis for preparing the specified new assembly while leaving code interpretation and system protection decisions with the responsible design professionals.

03 / START A CONVERSATION

Let’s talk about your project.

Tell us what you’re working on and the details you have so far. You can include drawings and other documents in your email.

Prefer to call? (951) 403-5738

Email sales: saleselectricalbuyers@gmail.com

PROJECT INQUIRY01 — 04

* Required fields. This form opens your email application; send the prepared message there, or email us directly. You can also call (951) 403-5738.